On the right kind of brooding ~ why we shouldn’t fear ruminating

On the right kind of brooding ~ why we shouldn’t fear ruminating

A week or two back, I sneaked out late at night to put down food for the hedgehogs. On the other side of the pond to the patio, I was being watched by beady duck eyes and I saw that Mrs Duck was observing me. She’d spread her wings out, to shelter all her ducklings. Now they’d been getting bigger by the day and would no longer fit under her tummy so she was trying to keep the cold night from her precious little fluffies by using her wings as an umbrella. I apologised for disturbing her and went in, brooding on, well, brooding.

The first thing that came to mind was the poem Peace by Gerard Manley Hopkins:

WHEN will you ever, Peace, wild wooddove, shy wings shut,
Your round me roaming end, and under be my boughs?
When, when, Peace, will you, Peace? I’ll not play hypocrite
To own my heart: I yield you do come sometimes; but
That piecemeal peace is poor peace. What pure peace allows
Alarms of wars, the daunting wars, the death of it?
O surely, reaving Peace, my Lord should leave in lieu
Some good! And so he does leave Patience exquisite,
That plumes to Peace thereafter. And when Peace here does house
He comes with work to do, he does not come to coo,
He comes to brood and sit.

We’re used to the word BROOD being used in a negative manner. It implies fretting, chewing over an issue, worrying. The first use of it for a process of incubating thoughts or feelings in the mind came probably in the late sixteenth century, but the word originates with the way hens and other birds care for their hatchlings.

Observing that mother duck made me think about how reluctant we can be to sit with our thoughts, to nurture and develop them. Many systems of therapy decry what is often referred to as fruitless ruminating, that process of endlessly turning over a troubling topic in the mind, returning time and again to try and tease out answers. The implication is that it’s pointless and we need to step away and stop hashing it over in a bid to find resolution. The term ruminating is used but in a negative manner. To me, to ruminate is to imitate the digestive processes of certain kinds of multi-stomached animals who extract every ounce of goodness and nutrition out of their fodder. It’s a long process, full of gurgling and chewing of the cud. From the outside, an animal (or a person) engaged in ruminating may seem inactive and even lazy. But work is being done at a deep level.

To sit with a problem, to incubate it (both in a bird-brooding way and perhaps also in the manner of the ancients who would sleep and dream at a temple to seek an answer to their question) is something we may have forgotten how to do, in our goal-orientated society that rushes at things. Much modern psychotherapy seems geared towards easing troubled people away from this process rather than enabling them with better tools and techniques. Jung commented that often insoluble problems of the mind would stop being troublesome as the person reached greater maturity of psyche; the problem did not go away but its importance faded as the person continued to do their soul work (“I had always worked with the temperamental conviction that at bottom there were no insoluble problems, and experience justified me in so far as I have seen patients simply outgrow a problem that has destroyed others. This ‘outgrowing’ as I formerly called it proved on further investigation to be a new level of consciousness. Some higher or wider interest appeared on the patient’s horizon, and through this broadening of his outlook the insoluble problem lost its urgency”- Commentary on The Secret of the Golden Flower). He also wrote, “When we must deal with problems, we instinctively refuse to try the way that leads through darkness and obscurity. We wish to hear only unequivocal results, and completely forget that these results can only be brought about when we have ventured into and emerged again from the darkness.” (MMSS p97) He also said, “”Go to bed. Think on your problems. See what you dream. Perhaps the 2,000,000 year old man will speak. Only in a cul-de-sac do you hear his voice.” (JS p359)

To really brood on what troubles you is to explore those dark places and find light and treasure and bring it back with you. The process of seeking often brings quite different results to those you thought you were looking for, which may also explain Jung’s observation that an insoluble problem was at times outgrown and ceased itself to have the same importance. I’m in a proper cul-de-sac, unable to move in any direction at present. Perhaps I must just wait and brood and see what emerges from the darkness beneath my wings.


12 thoughts on “On the right kind of brooding ~ why we shouldn’t fear ruminating

  1. Viv thank you … brood is a lovely word, just the sound of it is deep and beautifully dark and a wonderful metaphor used in your post. Digesting takes time which is to be allowed.
    I like too Jung’s reminder that we outgrow things – as we grow –

  2. Brooding/ ruminating is a wildly underrated quality. I’m all for bringing it back. I have been known to wander around the house, cow-like, deep in thought, and perhaps that means rumination…

    • Yes indeed. It’s actually become a term of denigration; saw it used in a book on CBT I read (and almost threw at the wall)

  3. My very favourite poet, although not poem I knew. How he twists familiar words to wring out deepest evocations! ‘Patience exquisite’ is like a Victorian needlepoint. We are so driven by doing that rumination is seen as unproductive but you, like Hopkins, make it a deeper production, a wresting rather than a deflection. A good post-election post; after frenzy and half-truths, viciousness and hostility the need to chew the cud of what it might in quiet yeild!

  4. I looked up the German word vor brooding – Grübelei –
    The sound is playful, and makes me smile. We learn every day from nature, and what a blessing to have a few wise creatures in one’s garden. You never know, your brooding may hatch a thought with wings.

  5. Ah, interesting post indeed. Not many people allow the time needed for Jungian brooding, ruminating these days. We want quick fixes, even for crises of the soul. We plaster the dark with light but it still seeps out, round the edges. Only by exploring the depths can some issues be resolved, and even then not always. Often we will spiral, in and out of the dark places, gulping for air at the top before plunging back in again. Grubby work, this soul work, huh?
    I really like this post. It’s timely for me too.
    I also like the reminder that sometimes we outgrow our issues…often, I feel, we can hang onto stuff almost by habit or nostalgia…yet, when we examine it, the initial charge has …dissipated. xx

  6. Beautiful post, Viv – and some beautiful comments above, too.
    I believe the darkness has beauty, as the light does. And any strength I have comes in the acceptance of both, as day follows night follows day…
    Or, as Popeye put it, “I yam what I yam.”

    • Darkness has been demonised by those who love the light too much.
      Next volume of poetry is called A Box of Darkness and I believe it to be beautiful.
      I don’t always reply to comments; sometimes I find myself feeling overwhelmed by the power of them, put off replying and the moment is past. The comments here are uplifting and wonderful.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.